The Best Islands for Vacation Homes in Bahamas (2025)

Hi, I’m Glenn Ferguson—Luxury Bahamas Real Estate Agent and Residency Consultant.

With over 15 years of experience helping international buyers find their perfect island escape, I’ve developed a deep understanding of where luxury, lifestyle, and investment potential intersect across our 700 islands and cays. Whether you’re looking for a serene retreat, an income-generating property, or a statement home in paradise, I’m here to guide you every step of the way. Let’s talk about your vision for a vacation home in the Bahamas.

My Top Picks for Bahamas Vacation Homes (Based on Your Goals)

The Bahamas isn’t a one-size-fits-all destination—it’s a mosaic of 700 islands, each offering unique lifestyles and investment opportunities. Over my 15-year career, I’ve seen buyers thrive when their island choice aligns perfectly with their goals. Whether you’re chasing rental income, celebrity-worthy privacy, or a boating paradise, here’s my list of 2025’s top islands (and why they’ll work for you). Think of this as your GPS to paradise—no more guesswork, just strategic matches.

🏝️ Paradise Island: For High-Profile Luxury

“If you want to be steps from Atlantis and Four Seasons, with Miami just 30 minutes by air…”

Paradise Island is the epitome of high-end living. It offers exclusive communities like Ocean Club Estates, where homes start at $5M and can exceed $20M for waterfront properties. If you’re looking for something ultra-modern, Aqualina’s oceanfront residences are a standout option, starting at $15M. These properties combine world-class amenities with unparalleled views of the turquoise Bahamian waters.

This area is also ideal for those who value convenience. Its proximity to Nassau means you’ll have access to fine dining, luxury shopping, and private schools while still enjoying the privacy of an exclusive enclave. Inventory here is tight due to high demand from U.S. buyers, so if Paradise Island is on your radar, I’d recommend acting quickly.

🌺 Harbour Island: Old-World Charm Meets Privacy

“For celebrities and CEOs who want pink sand beaches and zero paparazzi…”

Harbour Island is a favorite among high-profile individuals seeking privacy and charm. Known for its iconic Pink Sands Beach, this island offers a blend of historic architecture and modern luxury. My team recently closed a $12M beachfront estate here that included a private dock—perfect for boating enthusiasts or those who value direct ocean access.

Vacation rentals on Harbour Island are in high demand, with nightly rates averaging $10K+ during peak seasons. This makes it an excellent choice for buyers looking to offset costs through short-term rentals while enjoying their property part-time. If you’re drawn to boutique shopping, gourmet dining, and an atmosphere steeped in Bahamian culture, Harbour Island might be your perfect match.

🐠 The Exumas: Ultimate Seclusion

“If owning a private cay or a villa near the swimming pigs sounds like your slice of heaven…”

The Exumas offer unparalleled seclusion and natural beauty. This chain of 365 islands is famous for its crystal-clear waters and unique attractions like the swimming pigs at Big Major Cay. For those seeking ultimate privacy, I’ve helped clients secure private islands such as Fowl Cay (accommodating up to 28 guests) and Musha Cay, owned by illusionist David Copperfield.

These properties are not only stunning but also lucrative investments. Rental yields in the Exumas range from 8–12% annually due to high demand from affluent travelers seeking exclusive experiences. Whether you’re interested in a private cay or a luxury villa with direct beach access, the Exumas deliver unmatched tranquility and investment potential.

⛵ Abacos: Boating Enthusiasts’ Paradise

“Want to wake up, step onto your dock, and sail to Hope Town’s candy-striped lighthouse?”

The Abacos are a dream destination for boating enthusiasts and yachters. Communities like Baker’s Bay Golf & Ocean Club on Great Guana Cay offer marina-front homes with direct access to some of the best sailing waters in the world. Prices in this region rose 15% last year due to increasing demand for waterfront properties with private docks and luxury amenities.

The Abacos also cater to families looking for a laid-back lifestyle with excellent fishing, diving, and community-focused events like regattas. If you’re considering pre-construction opportunities or custom builds in this area, now is the time to invest before prices climb further.

FAQ: What My Clients Ask

You're not alone — here are the questions I hear most from buyers exploring Bahamas vacation homes. Based on 15+ years of experience, these answers cut through the noise to give you practical, Bahamas-specific insights you won't find on generic real estate sites. Let's tackle what's keeping you up at night, from taxes to hurricanes (spoiler: you're safer here than you think)

P.S. Don't see your question. DM me - I reply personally within 24 hours.

1. Q: “What’s the minimum investment for a luxury vacation home?”
   • A: Entry points vary based on location:
     • $2.5M+ in Nassau/Paradise Island
     • $1.8M+ for turnkey villas in Eleuthera
     • $6M+ for private islands (Exumas)
2. Q: “Can I get residency by buying property?”
   • A: Yes! Purchases over $1.5M qualify for the Bahamas’ Economic Permanent Residency (EPR) program.
     • I’ll handle all the paperwork and connect you with immigration attorneys to fast-track your application.
3. Q: “How are property taxes handled?”
   • A: The Bahamas offers significant tax advantages:
     • No income or capital gains taxes.
     • Stamp duty: 2.5–10% (one-time at purchase).
     • Annual property tax: 0.5–1% of assessed value.
4. Q: “What about hurricanes?”
   • A: I only recommend properties built with hurricane-resistant features like impact windows and elevated foundations.
     • Insurance typically runs about 1.2% of your home’s value annually.
5. Q: “Can I rent my home when I’m not there?”
   • A: Absolutely! My network manages 85% of luxury rentals here.
     • Depending on location, you can expect gross rental income ranging from $5K–$50K+ per week.

Let’s Make It Happen

Ready to explore? Here’s how I help my clients turn their dreams into reality:

1. Match You to the Right Island: I’ll ask about your hobbies, family needs, and investment goals to identify your perfect location—whether it’s Paradise Island’s luxury or Exuma’s seclusion.
2. Residency Guidance: With my connections to top immigration attorneys, I’ll streamline your residency application process.
3. Full Concierge Service: From vetting properties to arranging private jet transfers or yacht charters, I handle every detail so you can focus on enjoying your new home.

Why Work With Me?

I’m not just selling homes—I’m helping you create a lifestyle that blends relaxation with smart investment strategies in one of the world’s most beautiful destinations.

📞 Call/WhatsApp me at +1-(242)-395-8495 or ASK Glenn

P.S. Mention this note for a complimentary VIP island tour—I’ll personally show you hidden gems not listed online.

Whether you’re drawn to Paradise Island’s vibrancy, Harbour Island’s charm, Exuma’s privacy, or Abaco’s nautical appeal, there’s no better time than now to invest in your dream vacation home in the Bahamas.

Let me help make it happen—because paradise isn’t just a destination; it’s a lifestyle waiting for you here in the Bahamas.

— Glenn Ferguson

"Your Key to Bahamas Luxury Living"